Rare SOV Coins
Home › Numismatic Guides › British Gold Coinage
British Gold Coinage

British Gold Guineas & Five Guineas: Reigns, Types & Rarity

Discover the West African gold origins, 21-shilling stabilisation, Elephant & Castle provenance marks, and monumental Five Guineas of Stuart and Hanoverian Britain.

From West African Gold to Britain's Premier Trade Coin

Introduced in 1663 under Charles II, the gold guinea took its name from the Guinea coast of West Africa, where the Company of Royal Adventurers (later the Royal African Company) sourced the gold. Coins struck from company gold bear the small 'Elephant' or 'Elephant and Castle' privy mark beneath the monarch's bust—one of British numismatics' most sought-after provenance emblems.

Struck in 22-carat crown gold (.9167 fineness) at a standard weight of 8.35 to 8.40 grams, the guinea initially floated in value against silver shillings between 20 and 30 shillings. In 1717, Master of the Mint Sir Isaac Newton formally fixed the guinea at 21 shillings, cementing its role in British commerce, horse racing, and professional fees long after minting ceased.

  • 1663 Charles II: First milled British gold guinea (8.38 g nominal, 25 mm diameter)
  • Elephant & Castle / EIC / LIMA / VIGO marks indicate specific gold bullion provenance
  • 1717 Isaac Newton tariff: Fixed the guinea permanently at 21 shillings (£1.05)
  • Quarter, Third, Half, One, Two, and Five Guinea denominations formed the full gold suite

Five Guineas: Crown Jewels of Stuart and Hanoverian Coinage

Weighing roughly 41.75 grams of 22-carat gold (over 1.23 troy ounces of pure gold) and measuring 37–38 mm across, the Five Guineas coin was the largest regular-issue milled gold coin in British history. Struck across the reigns of Charles II, James II, William & Mary, William III, Anne, George I, and George II, surviving examples remain genuinely rare in all grades.

Among the pinnacle rarities of the series is Queen Anne's 1703 'VIGO' Five Guineas, struck from gold captured during the Anglo-Dutch naval victory at Vigo Bay in 1702, alongside her 1711 Post-Union second-bust Five Guineas bearing the revised arms of Great Britain following the 1707 Act of Union.

  • 1703 Anne 'VIGO' Five Guineas: Fewer than 20 examples believed surviving worldwide
  • 1706–1714 Anne Post-Union Five Guineas: Features united England/Scotland shield arms
  • 1729 George II 'E.I.C.' Five Guineas: Struck from East India Company gold
  • 1746 George II 'LIMA' Five Guineas: Commemorates bullion seized by Admiral Anson

George III Spade Guineas and the 1813 Military Guinea

During George III's long reign, the guinea evolved through five distinct portraits, culminating in the iconic 1787–1799 'Spade' Guinea—named after its clean, spade-shaped royal arms shield on the reverse. Because Napoleonic War paper currency restrictions drove gold out of circulation, Crisp Mint State Spade Guineas remained hoarded in country estates and banking vaults.

The final chapter came in 1813 with the 'Military' Guinea, struck specifically to pay the Duke of Wellington's troops campaigning in the Iberian Peninsula. Only ~360,000 were coined before the Great Recoinage of 1816 replaced the 21-shilling guinea with the 20-shilling sovereign.

  • 1787–1799 Spade Guinea: Most widely recognised George III gold type; beware modern brass gaming tokens
  • 1797–1800 Seven Shillings (Third Guinea): Introduced to relieve wartime silver shortages
  • 1813 Military Guinea: Garter shield reverse; last regular-issue British guinea
  • 1768–1777 Pattern Five Guineas by Tanner & Yeo: Ultra-rare George III museum pieces

Distinguishing Authentic Guineas from Brass Gaming Counters

Eighteenth- and nineteenth-century card players extensively used cheap brass 'Spade Guinea' gaming tokens inscribed 'IN MEMORY OF THE GOOD OLD DAYS' or carrying nonsensical legends. While harmless period curiosities, worn or gilt-plated brass counters occasionally deceive novice buyers who mistake the familiar Spade reverse for genuine 22ct gold.

Genuine Spade Guineas weigh 8.38–8.40 grams (versus ~5–6 grams for brass counters), display crisp crowned royal legends ('M.B.F.ET.H.REX...'), and feature fine chevron-milled edges. On Five Guineas, edge inscriptions ('DECUS ET TUTAMEN' plus regnal year) must match the obverse date without casting seams.

  • Read the full reverse legend: real guineas never carry 'GOOD OLD DAYS' gaming mottos
  • Weigh accurately: 8.35–8.40 g for a full guinea; 41.70–41.90 g for Five Guineas
  • Check edge lettering regnal year on Five Guineas (e.g., DECIMO for 1711 Anne)
  • Examine high-grade guineas for subtle adjustment marks (mint file marks used to calibrate planchet weight)

British Guinea Denominations & Key Provenance Marks

Denomination / TypeNominal Weight (.9167 Au)Edge DesignKey Rarity / Provenance Drivers
Five Guineas (1668–1753)41.75 g (1.231 oz AGW)DECUS ET TUTAMEN + regnal yearVIGO (1703), E.I.C. (1729), LIMA (1746), Post-Union Anne
Two Guineas (1664–1753)16.76 g (0.494 oz AGW)Diagonal / chevron millingLow mintages across Charles II, Anne, George I & II
One Guinea (1663–1813)8.38 g (0.247 oz AGW)Diagonal / chevron millingElephant & Castle marks, 1787–99 Spade, 1813 Military
Half Guinea (1669–1813)4.19 g (0.1235 oz AGW)Diagonal / chevron millingHeavily circulated; scarce in uncirculated grades
Third Guinea (1797–1813)2.79 g (0.0823 oz AGW)Diagonal millingThree distinct George III obverse/reverse types

Early milled gold blanks frequently show parallel mint-applied adjustment marks from pre-strike weight calibration; light adjustment marks do not indicate post-mint damage.

Worked Illustration: Verifying a Queen Anne 1711 Post-Union Five Guineas

This worked illustration walks through the metrological and archival checks applied to a Queen Anne 1711 Five Guineas (2nd Bust, Post-Union) coin.

  1. Step 1 (Weight & fineness check): Weigh the piece on a 0.01 g analytical balance; a genuine intact Five Guineas measures ~41.7–41.9 g in 22ct (.9167) gold, giving ~1.23 oz fine gold.
  2. Step 2 (Heraldic attribution): Confirm the reverse displays the Post-Union arms introduced after 1707—England and Scotland impaled at 12 and 6 o'clock, France at 3 o'clock, and Ireland at 9 o'clock.
  3. Step 3 (Edge regnal year verification): Verify the raised edge inscription reads DECUS ET TUTAMEN ANNO REGNI DECIMO, matching Queen Anne's tenth regnal year (1711).
  4. Step 4 (Surface & pedigree review): Inspect for honest AU58/EF cabinet wear versus tooling, and cross-check any prior auction pedigree (such as historic London or European sales).

Worked Illustration Outcome: Correct Post-Union heraldry, matching DECIMO regnal edge, ~41.8 g 22ct weight, and verified surface originality establish both physical authenticity and catalogued rarity.

Six-Point Guinea & Five Guineas Verification Checklist

  • Weigh the coin against its exact denomination standard (8.38 g guinea, 16.76 g two guineas, 41.75 g five guineas).
  • Check edge lettering (Five Guineas) or chevron/diagonal reeding (Guineas and Half Guineas).
  • Confirm authentic Latin royal titles rather than eighteenth-century gaming token inscriptions.
  • Examine beneath the bust for provenance marks (Elephant & Castle, VIGO, E.I.C., LIMA) and verify die alignment.
  • Distinguish original Royal Mint planchet adjustment lines from harsh post-mint abrasive cleaning.
  • Compare against Spink and Schneider/Murdoch auction plates for Five Guineas die characteristics.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is a guinea worth 21 shillings instead of 20 shillings like a sovereign?

Although originally struck as a 20-shilling gold coin in 1663, rising gold prices caused the guinea to trade above face value until 1717, when Sir Isaac Newton fixed its official tariff at 21 shillings (£1.05).

What do 'VIGO', 'E.I.C.', and 'LIMA' mean beneath a monarch's portrait?

They are bullion provenance marks engraved by the Royal Mint: VIGO denotes treasure captured at Vigo Bay (1702), E.I.C. stands for East India Company gold, and LIMA marks South American bullion captured during Admiral Anson's voyage.

Are file marks across an 18th-century guinea always considered damage?

Not necessarily. Royal Mint workers routinely filed slightly heavy gold blanks prior to striking to meet weight tolerances. Authentic mint 'adjustment marks' appear beneath struck design detail and are distinct from post-mint scratches.

Why are brass Spade Guinea tokens so common in UK estate lots?

Whist and card players in the Georgian and Victorian eras used inexpensive gilt brass Spade Guinea imitations as gaming counters; they carry negligible precious-metal value compared with 22ct gold guineas.

Primary References & Standards

  • Spink & Son, Coins of England & the United Kingdom (Standard Catalogue of British Coins).
  • Bull, Maurice, English Gold Coinage (2 vols.), Spink & Son.
  • Newton, Isaac, Mint Reports and the 1717 Guinea Valuation Proclamation, Royal Mint Museum Archives.

Related Numismatic Guides